evenwiththemoon



Recent works

Recent series

  1. Words:
    2,151
    Works:
    1
  2. Words:
    4,603
    Works:
    2
    Bookmarks:
    8

Recent bookmarks

  1. Public Bookmark 8

    Tags
    Summary

    “I’m no good,” John says, voice cracking. “Why d’you even…” The words for what they are stick. 

    Once something is real it’s easier to lose.

    Arthur pulls John’s face back around, shifting his grip to one side of his jaw and raising the other to mirror it, tilting him firmly towards Arthur’s soft blue eyes. “Y’mean why do I love you?” 

    He says it almost angry.

    John remembers Arthur’s lips in his hair while he lay in that cot in the mountains, wrapped in bandages and half-insane with fever. “Love you,” they’d mouthed against his skull, through unwashed hair and flecked by blood when pulled away. “Love you John Marston, you stupid bastard.”

    Now, he shudders apart like a fresh-shot hare. And then he nods, small.

    ------

    A gift for my new friend cokobi, who gave me the prompt for this fic: an insecure John receiving reassurance from Arthur, after some jealousy regarding Charles. (Note that there's no Charles bashing here, because in this house we love Charles.)

    Language:
    English
    Words:
    8,118
    Chapters:
    1/1
    Comments:
    3
    Kudos:
    85
    Bookmarks:
    8
    Hits:
    641

    29 Jan 2026

  2. Public Bookmark 19

    Tags
    Summary

    From the moment of his birth, Arthur Morgan’s life was never going to be an easy one.

     

    And if that doesn’t hit Arthur like a sucker punch to the gut. He ain’t used to people caring to know him beyond what he puts on the table. Dutch and Hosea have always appreciated his ability to aim and shoot a gun, intimidate a mark, get a job done. Miss Grimshaw is grateful for the chores he does around camp without complaint. And John – well, John’s always just seemed to lap up whatever Arthur is willing to give him. The idea that John wants more – wants to really know Arthur, to see him, a part of him no-one else is interested in, it flares up some kind of unfamiliar fear inside of Arthur’s chest.

    Language:
    English
    Words:
    142,312
    Chapters:
    15/16
    Comments:
    57
    Kudos:
    89
    Bookmarks:
    19
    Hits:
    2,059

    25 Jan 2026

  3. Public Bookmark 73

    Tags
    Summary

    “I’ve gone crazy,” he concludes aloud.

    This must be the answer, because his dreams are never this stable, and he doesn’t believe in ghosts. He’s finally lost his ever-loving mind. The grief must have been too much. He’s become one of those men driven insane by tragedy.

    “It’s me,” Arthur says, voice raspy around the edges. “You’re not crazy, John.”

    _______

    John spends two years trying and failing to move on. Returning to the States, he makes the most unlikely and infuriating discovery of the new century. Life has provided a second chance, and John refuses to let it go to waste.

    Series
    Language:
    English
    Words:
    218,399
    Chapters:
    25/25
    Comments:
    276
    Kudos:
    699
    Bookmarks:
    73
    Hits:
    13,863

    11 Jan 2026

  4. Public Bookmark 27

    Tags
    Summary

    “Hey,” Arthur says softly and reaches over, rubbing over the top of John’s back firmly, “S’gonna work out, John.”

    “I just… I wish I was,” John whispers, “Normal. I tried with Abi but that weren’t fair to her and it just… It just made me feel bad.”

    Arthur frowns at him softly and lightens his touch, gently rubbing up and down the younger man’s spine.

    “I just wanna forget about it,” John admits weakly and closes his eyes.

    “Forget about what?”

    “… I’m just gonna stay out here and be alone,” John’s brows furrow and he lifts his head to look up at Arthur, “Is that too suspicious?”

    “I… No, I guess not.”

    “I mean no one thinks you're gay,” John rubs at his eyes tiredly then stills, peeking over his hand at Arthur, “Sorry.”

    Language:
    English
    Words:
    5,532
    Chapters:
    1/1
    Comments:
    12
    Kudos:
    212
    Bookmarks:
    27
    Hits:
    1,541

    23 Dec 2025

  5. Rec 25

    Tags
    Summary

    "Can you tip your head back?" Arthur asks and he sounds hesitant, a little ashamed, "Just a bit."

    "Mm… Move me," John says, hoarse, "I don't know what you want."

    Arthur goes very quiet for a moment then leans back in, two fingers under John's chin, tilting the younger’s head back, exposing his neck.

    John’s eyelids flutter for a moment, feeling exposed.

    "This ain’t how I sleep," John whispers, teasing.

    "It's how I want you."

    John almost curses at the pang of heat low in his gut that makes his toes curl in his socks.

    Language:
    English
    Words:
    3,814
    Chapters:
    1/1
    Comments:
    8
    Kudos:
    225
    Bookmarks:
    25
    Hits:
    2,827

    19 Dec 2025