Chapter Text
Things had gone well at the school. When Alyssa’s parents explained everything to the principal and how John was volunteering to take Alyssa in, the situation was made a bit clearer. Besides, Lexi had good grades, and by now, every teacher knew that she was helping two problem children to get better grades too. But what’s more important, the principal also knew of the very real possibility that she was talking to the future School District Inspector right there and then; she knew it was just good business to be in John’s good graces.
The usual questions followed along: “Can you provide a safe environment for Alyssa?” “Will Alyssa be able to keep her grades up?” “Does Alyssa have everything she needs?”, and while on paper these questions made sense, in reality, John thought this was needless bureaucracy: Mike and Grace needed time away, he had stepped up to help, and that’s all that should matter.
Of course, he also understood that the principal was covering her own bases; in case something happened, she could wash her hands of the whole situation. In the end, everybody wanted to win, and everybody wanted to steer clear should something go wrong.
It wasn’t the last time that John had to deal with bureaucracy when it came to Alyssa, however. Becoming a guardian, even if it was temporary, was a bit of a nightmare. The easier path forward was to sign a notarized letter in which it was stated that both Mike, Grace, and John agreed to the process; they all signed it, but it wasn’t made official until almost a week later, as John was subjected to background checks and several interviews.
In the meantime, both Alyssa and Lexi were happy; they were studying together, doing homework together, and just having fun. Seeing his little girl having so much fun made the whole thing worth for John, and seeing how Alyssa seemed to be more relaxed around him also motivated him. He could understand how difficult things could be in a household when the parents were feuding; on the other hand, he also understood how difficult it was to focus on saving a marriage when there were constant distractions.
In the end, John became Alyssa’s guardian, and he was granted the minimum period of six months, which was open to further discussion: Either the agreement could be ended earlier, or it could be extended further if both parents deemed it necessary.
Mike and Grace thanked John for everything he was doing for their family, and John, as a kind man as he was, simply told them that it was nothing, and so, Alyssa’s parents went home to try their best to save their marriage, not before kissing and hugging Alyssa and telling her how much they loved her.
Those were a few stressful days for John; he understood the need for such scrutiny, but at times, he felt the interviewer was making things needlessly complicated. To her credit, Lexi shouldered most of the responsibility of making Alyssa feel welcomed. They were always together, they were always chatting, and they were up to some mischief. More than once John had to ask them to settle down and get to bed, and even after the lights were off, he could hear them snickering and laughing, just before falling asleep.
Alyssa couldn’t be happier; although she had just endured a week of her parents feuding, she had seen the worst of it, and that meant that she was on edge even in her own home. She wanted an escape, at least one sleepover with Lexi to try and forget about her situation, and she had gotten much more than she hoped for.
The redhead had a bit of a crush on Lexi, and while she was relatively good at hiding it, the more time she spent with the blonde girl, the harder it became for her to control herself. When she saw Lexi with Randy and Jimmy during recess that day, she felt many things: Curiosity, a bit of disgust, but above all, jealousy.
Like every other kid in her class, she had been fast to categorize the boys as problem children and moved on, thinking of them as weirdos and pervs; she had even warned Lexi that they would turn her into a perv too.
But deep inside, she couldn’t forget what she saw and what she heard. The muffled voices, the tones of urgency, Lexi’s cute moans. She then wondered if problem kids like those too could really be that bad if Lexi wasn’t only giving them a chance but also getting that close to them.
Alyssa spent time wondering if it was wrong of her to crush on Lexi like that; she gave her some room, and there were some days when they didn’t talk that much, but every time they would hang out, she felt wonderful, and every time she looked at Lexi, Alyssa’s heart skipped a beat.
Of course, she knew about girls who liked girls, and through the not-too-discreet conversations that Randy and Jimmy would have with one another, she also knew that girls could go all the way. She freaked out a little when she started to think of Lexi as something more than just her very good friend who knew her like no one else, and she started to wonder if she hadn’t turned into a weirdo and a perv herself. She didn’t even know if Lexi would be that receptive to her either; sure, she was messing with the boys and everything, but surely she wouldn’t do the same thing with a girl. Alyssa sighed, frustrated with herself; she wanted to make a move so she at least would know if Lexi felt the same about her, but her own crippling doubts stopped her.
Until that day, that special day that she spent with Lexi doing homework and looking at her all she wanted, without fear of anyone else making fun of her. The more Alyssa thought about it, the more she realized she needed to reveal her secret to Lexi. She was prepared to lay her cards on the table, and she hoped for the best.
Alyssa had many doubts in her mind; she wanted to know if Lexi really liked Randy and Jimmy in that way, she also wanted to know if what they were doing to her felt that good, and of course, she wanted to know so many more things that she didn’t know how to ask about.
Lexi was surprised; she couldn’t even speak, and so Alyssa told her everything. The cute redhead was at a crossroads; this wasn’t about just trying on cute and sexy outfits that Lexi was more than happy to lend her, and this wasn’t just fantasizing about Lexi Callahan anymore; it was something much deeper and much more meaningful to her.
It’s fair to say that Alyssa got so much more than she bargained for.
Lexi wasn’t repulsed or weirded out by her, although she probably didn’t realize how much Alyssa really liked her. But for Alyssa, the way Lexi taught her to touch herself and reach her pleasure was the most intense thing she had experienced in her short life. It was intense, and her parents would probably never accept it, but to her, that changed things.
The next few days, while John dealt with paperwork and interviews, the girls grew even closer. Alyssa never really told her upfront that she liked her, but she had a feeling that Lexi knew. And the blonde girl remained just as generous and helpful to her as she had always been. Even if there wasn’t anything implicitly said, Alyssa was happy.
Of course, not everything was puppy love and crushes; Lexi had looked at Alyssa in a different light after they fooled around for a bit. Alyssa was receptive; she was asking questions just to sate her curiosity, and she seemed open to learning more. There were a lot of fun games between them, and on the surface, they even acted as sisters, but as soon as Lexi’s bedroom door would close, they would get back at it.
Lexi’s only experience kissing girls came from her brief time with her cousin Stacy; everything else, she was trying to learn as she moved on. She figured that Alyssa would enjoy being touched and the same way she touched herself, and so far, she had seen Alyssa’s cute face as she was reaching her orgasm many times, and the blonde girl wanted to see much more of her.
Lexi also started to lend Alyssa some of her skimpy underwear for her to wear to school. While Alyssa still wore normal clothes, feeling those diminutive panties under her skirt made her feel naughty and special, she started to feel like Lexi’s partner in crime, and it showed.
One day, when they were done with school for the day, John was waiting for them to tell them that he was now officially Alyssa’s guardian, and he wanted to take them out for pizza to celebrate the good news. The girls screamed, filled with happiness, and even hugged. Alyssa had been very close to trying to kiss Lexi, but seeing John there made her stop. He had been great to her; he was kind, considerate, and kind of cute, but she didn’t know how he would feel about her kissing Lexi.
To Lexi, this felt official, Alyssa was her sister. Well, not a full-blooded sister, of course, but that wasn’t a problem for the blonde girl. Full sister, half sister, pretend sister, she didn’t care about that; if she wanted to think of Alyssa as her sister, even if it was just for six months, no one would stop her.
As time continued to pass and Lexi and Alyssa continued to spend time together, John’s frustrations started to manifest themselves. With Alyssa being home, it was impossible to get some alone time with Lexi. Their movie nights became regular movie nights, and their trips to the mall were just innocent, non-assuming trips to the mall, and going out to watch movies at the theater or hit the occasional burger or pizza was just a wholesome family activity.
He missed his little girl; he missed her warmth and the way she felt in his arms.
Lexi had her hands full with Alyssa; she kept pushing her boundaries little by little, and the cute redhead was receptive to her ideas, even if she would blush and stammer. She was there with Lexi, in her room; she felt safe, and she played along with everything and anything the blonde girl wanted to do.
“So, Aly, how do you like living with me, huh?” Alyssa immediately smiled at the question as she looked at Lexi. The girls were working on the homework for the day; it had been two weeks since John had been made Alyssa’s guardian, and the redhead girl had more than enough time to adapt.
“I love it; you and your dad have been super cool to me. I love your room too, and I love that every day feels like when we were in preschool” Lexi chuckled, looking at Alyssa. “Well, I guess not exactly the same, right? Back then, we would each go to our house after school, and we wouldn’t see each other again, unless our parents wanted to visit”.
The redhead girl nodded, looking at her notebook. “Well, yeah, but you know what I mean, right?” Lexi nodded too. “Of course I do, silly… I like having you here with us, and my daddy too!” Lexi suddenly approached Alyssa and hugged her tightly. “So, what do you wanna do tonight?”.
Alyssa blushed, for the past couple of weeks, that question had had a very different connotation; it wasn’t an invitation to watch a movie or to listen to music. It was something twisted and perverse. The kisses and the masturbation were only the first step; Lexi had shown Alyssa different kinds of pleasure.
One night, while the two of them were completely naked, she had Alyssa stand in front of her full-length mirror, all while Lexi touched her from behind and even slid her fingers inside her cunny. She forced the cute redhead to look at her reflection; she was entranced by the expression on her face when she was fully aroused, and she freaked out a little when she saw how her body was subconsciously doing things, like spreading her legs whenever Lexi would tease her crotch or arching her back whenever Lexi wanted to cup her breasts.
Alyssa was being conditioned to react to Lexi’s touch, and her body learned to love the blonde girl. Since then, every time Lexi asked, “What do you want to do tonight?”, it was really an invitation to do something dirty and twisted, something that Alyssa would most likely enjoy but was still trying to work up the courage to admit.
“W-we could spend the night… You know, in bed?”.
Lexi chuckled at the most innocent suggestion she had heard. “Aw, come on! Just that?” Alyssa blushed again, nodding. “W-well… Yeah! What’s wrong with that? I like to cuddle” Lexi kept her smile; she was looking into Alyssa’s eyes. “Well, me too! But we do that every day anyway! No, come on, something fun!”.
Alyssa cleared her throat, still blushing, and smiling like a goof when Lexi made eye contact. “W-well… You could probably come out with a suggestion… Right? You are… Uh… Experienced in fun things”.
Lexi snickered, looking at her notebook. “Well, duh! I’d say… We could try and find a way to mess with the boys; that’d be hot” Alyssa gulped, looking at Lexi, almost as if she were alarmed. “But… I dunno, I mean, I promised them we would play again, but that was like… Weeks ago! They surely are ready to go” The redhead looked at her friend. “Are… Are you serious?”.
There was a brief silence between them. “You know I am! I mean, come on, you remember seeing me that day, right? And you liked what you saw! Imagine if you felt it too! Randy and Jimmy are very good at what they do” A big smile appeared on Alyssa’s face. “EW! Don’t be gross!”.
The two girls laughed as they continued working on their assignment. “No, but really… It gets… Hot, intense too… I think you’d like it” Alyssa looked at her, her heart beating fast. “I… You really are serious about this, aren’t you? I…” The cute redhead was flustered, and she returned to her notebook.
“I don’t even know where to start… I mean… When I saw you, yeah… They looked like they knew what they were doing, and you were having a good time too… But… I-I don’t know if I could do that”.
Lexi looked at Alyssa some more; she still had a smile on her face. “Well, they got better, you know? And they are so silly too! Whenever they get so worked up, they stumble around! It’s funny, but also it’s kinda hot to know you have that kind of effect on someone”.
Alyssa was more than aware that she stumbled over her words, blushed, and made a fool of herself whenever Lexi teased her, but it was part of the game. Lexi was never mean to her, and she had taken her in too; that was something she couldn’t ignore.
“Well, yeah, but you have that effect on everyone because you have a cute butt! And I don’t have a cute butt like that” Lexi grinned; she wasn’t going to miss her chance. “Maybe, but your boobies are bigger than mine! And some boys have noticed them already!”.
The redhead froze in place, and then she felt her ears getting hot. She was aware that her breasts were bigger than Lexi, but she felt a special kind of way whenever the blonde girl pointed that out. “And trust me, Aly, even if most guys go for big butts, there are a lot of guys who go for big boobies like yours!”.
Alyssa threw a pillow at Lexi. “Stop messing with me!” She protested while giggling. “What? It’s the truth! Aly, you’re super cute! And I know you feel super cute whenever you walk around wearing my panties; tell me I’m lying!”.
The redhead covered her face with her hands. “Oh my God, Lexi! You’re impossible!” The blonde girl climbed on top of her, kissing her neck from behind; she knew that Alyssa almost completely shut down whenever she kissed her neck. “T-that’s not fair, Lexi!” The blonde girl giggled, going as far as licking the back of her neck. “Come on, confess! You feel super cute and hot whenever you walk around in my panties. Admit it!”.
Alyssa finally looked over her shoulder, still trying to recover from those tiny neck kisses. “O-okay fine… I like how they feel, alright? Is that enough?” Lexi had an impish grin on her. “And why do you like how they feel? Come on, you don’t get to chicken out!” The redhead grabbed a pillow and screamed into it; she looked at Lexi again.
“You’re such a dirty girl, Lexi; maybe those two boys turned you into a perv after all!” Lexi chuckled, sticking her tongue out. “Or maybe it was me who turned them into pervs! And I’m gonna do that to you too!”.
She attacked Alyssa by tickling her; the two girls started to giggle, and as soon as Alyssa lay on her back, Lexi pecked her lips. The redhead girl gulped as she looked into Lexi’s eyes. “So? Are you gonna tell me, or do I have to tickle you until you confess?” Alyssa giggled, shaking her head. “Okay fine, I like how they feel because… I feel hot, I… I kinda get excited, and after an hour or two, I feel like I could cum… And I imagine you looking at me, and I almost lose it!”
“Now imagine it’s the boys looking at you” Lexi whispered into Alyssa’s ear; the redhead gasped. About a month ago, she would hate talking about Randy and Jimmy at all, but now, it doesn’t seem like a big deal to her, and Lexi is slowly getting her used to the idea of those two looking at her. “That’s pretty hot, right? Come on, don’t pretend it’s not!”.
At Lexi’s insistence, Alyssa couldn’t stop thinking about those two boys; they weren’t bad-looking, but their reputations made her immediately dislike them. As shallow and superficial as that sounded, it’s the way every kid in class behaved. Lexi pecked her lips again. “Confess!” She said with a big smile on her face. “Confess, or I’ll tickle you again!”.
Alyssa finally sighed and played with Lexi’s hair. She knew she was in a safe space with Lexi, and there was nothing to fear, but she still found it embarrassing to confess to such things. “Fine, fine… That’s… Kinda hot too… But you better not tell anyone!”.
Lexi chuckled; she felt strangely happy while Alyssa was playing with her hair. “And who am I supposed to tell? I mean, the boys? They’d probably want to play with you, and I don’t think that’s something you want, since, you know, you don’t like them that much”.
Alyssa fell silent for a few moments; she blushed one more time as she looked into Lexi’s eyes. “W-what would they do if they wanted to, uh… Play… With me? W-would they do to me the same thing they d-did to you?” Lexi pecked Alyssa’s lips again and shrugged. “I mean, probably! You’re super cute, Aly, but I think those two are intimidated by you… Still, if they had the chance, I think they would go for your boobies first!”.
She then grabbed Alyssa’s breasts through her top, causing the cute redhead to gasp and blush afterward. “L-Lexi… C’mon… W-we… Uh… W-we have homework…” The blonde girl shrugged. “So? We’re taking a break! That’s all; besides, this is nice, right?” She continued to fondle the redhead through her top; it wouldn’t be long for her nipples to get hard. “Do you like how this feels, Aly?” The redhead nodded slowly; she couldn’t take her eyes off of Lexi. “Y-you know I do… E-especially when it’s you”.
Lexi slid her hands under Alyssa’s top and underneath her bra. The redhead tried to stifle a moan; the blonde girl started teasing her nipples. “Yeah, of course you do! Because you got big boobies, and you like it when I play with your big boobies, right?”.
Alyssa whimpered; her face was completely flushed, still, she nodded. It was as if she were used to the kinds of games that Lexi liked to play. “Y-yeah…” Lexi got closer to her, whispering. “Now, imagine it’s the boys groping your boobies”.
Alyssa gasped; it’s not like it was hard to imagine, she had seen them doing something like that to Lexi, and if the blonde girl felt so good, maybe she could feel good too, especially if Lexi was watching her. “Aly, do you wanna play with the boys? Be honest”. The redhead bit her bottom lip, trying not to say anything, but Lexi’s touch and those damned blue eyes of hers were forcing all kinds of embarrassing answers from her.
“Y-yeah… M-maybe… I-I dunno…” Lexi chuckled, shaking her head. “You’re more confusing than Mr. Davis’ tests! Just be honest, Aly… I’m sure the boys would make you feel good too! I swear, their hands do things to you that you won’t forget!” The cute redhead whimpered, licking her lips. “And maybe, we could all go to hang out at Jimmy’s house, and… You know, have some fun?”.
Alyssa felt like her face was on fire, her breathing was labored, and she was loving having her nipples teased by Lexi. “Trust me, his house is huge! And he has all kinds of stuff in his room”.
Alyssa knew that what she saw that day between the boys and Lexi wasn’t the only adventure they had; Lexi had told her all kinds of things and most of her adventures, so she knew that Lexi was teasing her with the possibility of creating their own memories with the boys. Alyssa gasped when she realized that she could get to see the boys undressing and teasing Lexi, and what’s more, Lexi would definitely see when they undressed and teased her.
“I-I… I dunno… M-maybe?” Lexi chuckled, looking at her. “But it does sound like fun, right?” Lexi pinched Alyssa’s left nipple, causing her to moan; she nodded afterward. “Y-yeah… It sounds like fun…” Lexi got closer to Alyssa, pecking her lips one more time, and then kissing her neck. “Oh, God… Please… Lexi…” Despite her initial protests, a moan and a whimper signaled Lexi that she could do whatever she wanted and Alyssa would enjoy it.
Lexi started going down on Alyssa, kissing her neck, reaching for her chest, and then her abdomen. She started to undress her slowly, leaving only the tiny panties she had borrowed before. Lexi giggled. “These rode up so high that they are spreading your cunny lips! No wonder you’re so horny, Aly”.
The redhead couldn’t control herself; as soon as she felt Lexi’s tongue teasing her, she placed her hands on Lexi’s head. “Y-you’re so bad, Lexi…!” The blonde girl grinned, looking up at her flushed friend. “I know!” She continued to tease her, slowly spreading her legs further. Alyssa gasped as Lexi simply pulled the panties to the side and started licking her directly.
This hadn’t been exactly what Alyssa had fantasized about; she hoped that she would get to kiss Lexi once and Lexi would respond in kind. After that, she had no idea what would happen. And now, she was lying on her back, with her legs spread, while her best friend was pleasuring her. When Lexi started to finger her too, Alyssa moaned loudly, grinding her hips.
“You’re so wet, Aly!” Lexi was entranced by the way her friend was reacting to her touch, and smiling, she started nibbling on the redhead’s clit. Alyssa’s back immediately arched; her hands pushed Lexi’s head further. “Lexi!” She tried stifling yet another moan, but it had been impossible. Lexi had become a professional at teasing and pleasing her.
Lexi moaned while licking her, as she had also started to pleasure herself. She could only manage to pull down her shorts and slide her hand down to her cunny. Alyssa moaned again, grinding her hips hard. “I’m… I-I’m so close, Lexi!” Her nipples were hard and sensitive; even moving around felt incredible to her. She kept pushing Lexi until she started panting. “S-so… So close… P-please… Lexi…!”.
Alyssa’s next words were an incomprehensible mess; her muscles tensed and her back arched even more, and her orgasm caused her body to contort, making her feel even more pleasure. By the time she was catching her breath, Lexi was climbing back to her, kissing her slowly. Her kisses had stopped being innocent pecks; they were now grown-up kisses, with tongue, teeth, and a lot of lust.
The redhead held on to Lexi; the blonde girl was playing with her hair next. “D-did you mean what you said earlier?” Lexi looked down at Alyssa; she was looking right into her eyes. “Well, that depends! What do you mean exactly? I said a lot of stuff!” Alyssa snickered, shaking her head. “Come on! Are you gonna make me say it?” The blonde girl continued to play with her hair until the redhead girl finally sighed.
“Fine… The whole thing with… You know… Us, uh, hanging out with Randy and Jimmy… Did… did you mean that?”.
Lexi sat up, looking at Alyssa. “Only if you wanna do it… I mean, Aly, you know that we do a bunch of stuff no one else in class does, right? And… It feels good when I tease you and make you cum, but… Doing stuff with the boys is a little different”.
Alyssa blushed again, listening to Lexi. “Oh my God, can you please stop teasing me for five seconds!?” Lexi chuckled; she also loved the way Alyssa reacted to her. “B-but… What… What do you mean, different?” Lexi shrugged. “Well, I mean… The boys will probably want to go all the way, that’s definitely not the same as fingering someone, jerking off, or rubbing a dick against your ass”.
The redhead was speechless, not so much for the implication Lexi was making, but because she had now imagined that Lexi had gone all the way herself; she had figured that all her talk was just stuff she had seen somewhere, but speaking from experience changed everything.
“A-all the way? L-like…?” Lexi shrugged again. “Yeah, Aly, all the way… Like… Dick in a cunny kind of all the way, like cumming because of it kind of all the way” Alyssa stammered again. “I-I… I don’t… I really… I, uh…” After taking a few moments to compose herself, the redhead looked at Lexi. “Lexi… I, uh… I’ve… I’ve never been with anyone! I…”.
Lexi giggled, taking Alyssa’s hands and holding them. “I know, silly! And we gotta do something about it; the boys can be… You know, kind of quick; they won’t let you enjoy yourself, so we gotta do something about your first time”. Alyssa’s heart was pounding in her chest; she didn’t even know where to look; she couldn’t believe she was having this kind of conversation with her best friend.
“What do you mean!?” She was alarmed, maybe even a bit outraged, but she was also aroused. And Lexi knew her enough to know that. “Well, your first time, dummy! You gotta have your first time with someone that’ll make you feel special, and warm, and protected! That way, when you think back, you’ll only have good memories!”.
Alyssa was shaking because she was aroused just thinking about it, even if her mind was screaming at her to stop considering it, and because she knew that Lexi already had something in mind that, no matter how intense it was, she’d end up accepting.
“So… Someone special?” Lexi grinned, looking at her. “Yup! Someone special, someone who’s worth the whole ordeal, you know?”. Alyssa took a few moments to herself; she then looked at her best friend again. “W-well? D-do you have someone in mind?”.
“Yup! My daddy!”.
There was a very awkward silence between the two girls. Lexi was also getting excited just thinking about it, imagining how her dad would be able to take Alyssa’s first time, but most importantly, how Alyssa would change afterward. It was a win/win situation for her.
“What!?” One more time, Alyssa showed outrage that was barely concealing her arousal. “Aw come on! What’s wrong with my daddy? Don’t you like him?” Alyssa’s heart was pounding hard again, her mouth dried up, and she felt a strong knot in her abdomen. “Are you crazy? With your dad? He’s gonna kill us! Oh, my God! He’s going to kick me out!”.
Lexi squeezed the redhead’s hands. “Alyssa, I promise you, he won’t get mad, okay? I’ll talk to him, and you’ll see he’ll say yes! And things will get so much better!”.
Alyssa could scarcely believe what she was hearing. True, John wasn’t bad-looking; he was like a cute nerd, a cute nerd who was also a grown-up. She hadn’t thought of him in that regard, but now, thanks to Lexi, she couldn’t stop thinking about him. “How can you be so sure he’ll even entertain this idea? This is insane!”.
Lexi flashed a mischievous smile; it only took Alyssa a few seconds to realize what that unspoken gesture meant. “Oh… My God… You didn’t… No way!”.
“Aly, please! Everything that has happened to me since I spent the night with my daddy has been great! My outfits, what you saw me do with the boys, what I do to you… Everything! All that happened thanks to my daddy. Imagine what that could do for you!”.
It was a twisted and deranged logic, but Lexi seemed convinced of it, and Alyssa knew that her best friend wasn’t going to relent. “You’re serious, aren’t you?” Lexi approached her, whispering. “Aly, I swear to God, I can walk out this room right now, go find him, and tell him, and he’ll say yes”.
“W-wait, wait, wait!” Alyssa was panicking, but the arousal was so intense that she was also smiling. “C-could I think about it?” Lexi chuckled, looking at her. “You mean, really think about it, or pretend like you’re thinking about it when in reality you’ve already decided? Come on, Aly… Let’s be real sisters for one night, and let’s take care of daddy!”.
Alyssa Jones felt a knot in her throat, a quiver in her legs, and a shiver down her spine. She looked at Lexi again, and she just knew, no matter how much she tried to pretend, Lexi may have turned her into a pervert just like her.