Work Text:
## Part 1: Static and Selfhood
The eternal scarlet dusk of the Pentagram never truly dimmed, but a deeper, quieter shade of crimson settled over the Hazbin Hotel in what passed for night. The chaotic symphony of the damned—the distant screams, the cacophony of sinner-run traffic, the occasional explosion—faded to a low, persistent hum. Inside the grand, garish lobby, the silence was a living thing, thick and watchful.
You couldn’t sleep.
Your room, for all its kitschy, Charlie Morningstar-designed attempts at cheer (rainbow striped wallpaper, a stuffed goat demon with one button eye hanging loose), felt like a compression chamber. The walls seemed to press in, not with malice, but with a relentless, questioning pressure. *Who are you? What are you?* The questions were a swarm of gnats in your skull, a static of your own making that no amount of pillow-smothering could silence.
So you’d crept out, a phantom in socks, drawn by the faint, ghostly glow of the main chandelier. The lobby was a cathedral of absurdity, all art deco curves clashing with cartoonish demonic motifs. And there, in the heart of it, silhouetted against the large, circular window that looked out onto the neon-soaked streets, was another phantom.
Alastor.
He wasn’t doing anything particularly sinister. No eldritch shadows coiled, no radio dials spun in his eyes. He was simply… there. Leaning against the grand piano, one hand resting on its lacquered lid, staring out at Hell’s relentless nightlife. The green glow from his microphone staff, propped against the piano bench, painted his sharp features in an eerie light. The ever-present smile was present, of course, a razor-cut in the gloom.
You froze, mid-step on the staircase. Every instinct, every overheard warning from the more cautious residents (which was everyone but Charlie), screamed to turn back. The Radio Demon. The Smiling Overlord. The deal-maker whose contracts were written in soul-ink. He’d been a semi-civil participant in Charlie’s redemption project, but his motives were opaque, his patience thin, and his humor fatal.
You were about to retreat when his ear—the long, tufted, deer-like appendage—twitched. Not much. Just a flick. He didn’t turn.
“Loathe as I am to interrupt a perfectly good bout of nocturnal pacing, my dear, you’ll wear a trench in the carpet,” his voice crackled into the silence, not from his body, but from the old-fashioned gramophone horn in the corner. It was layered with static, a vintage broadcast from a bygone era of terror. “And Charlie just had it cleaned. Bloodstains are one thing, but scuff marks? Truly sinful.”
Caught. Your heart, a useless muscle in this afterlife, hammered against your ribs. You could still flee. Mumble an apology and vanish.
Instead, a weariness deeper than any Hell could conjure settled in your bones. It was the fatigue of carrying a question with no answer, a weight that bent your spirit. And in that moment, the terrifying, enigmatic demon by the piano seemed… oddly neutral. A void. A sounding board in a sharp red suit. Perhaps that was what you needed.
You descended the rest of the stairs, your socks silent on the marble. “Couldn’t sleep,” you said, your own voice small against the rich timber of his broadcast.
“A common affliction in these parts!” he chirped, the static popping. “Nightmares, regrets, the gnawing realization of eternal damnation… the usual fare. Which flavor torments you tonight?”
He finally turned. His eyes, radio dials with thin crimson needles, fixed on you. The smile didn’t reach them. It never did. It was a flat, permanent performance.
You hugged yourself, approaching slowly until you stood near the overstuffed sofa, a battlefield of conflicting patterns. “Not… not nightmares. Not exactly.”
“Intriguing.” He pushed off the piano, gliding more than walking to the large, dark leather armchair that was unofficially his. He settled into it, crossing his legs, steepling his long, claw-tipped fingers. “Do regale me. I find the mundane miseries of the common sinner are often more entertaining than the grand torments. More… relatable.”
It was a trap. It had to be. He was a predator of emotion, feeding on fear and distress. To offer him your confusion was to serve yourself on a platter.
Yet, the words bubbled up, a toxic geyser you could no longer cap. The silence of the hotel, his waiting, predatory stillness, the sheer absurdity of having *this* crisis *here*, of all places… it broke the dam.
“It’s… me,” you started, the sentence crumbling as soon as it was built. You looked down at your hands. The hands of a sinner. They’d done bad things. They’d been stained. But were they… your hands? The body you wore in Hell—a reflection of your soul’s corruption, or your self-perception, or some divine joke—felt increasingly like a poorly fitted suit. A costume you’d been shoved into without your consent.
“Fascinatingly vague,” Alastor prompted, a hint of impatience like a needle scratch in his tone.
You took a shuddering breath. The ambient radio static around him seemed to lean in, listening. “I don’t know what I am.”
The statement hung there, pathetic and small.
Alastor’s head tilted, a bird-like, curious motion. “My dear, you are a sinner. You are dead. You are in Hell. You are, currently, a resident of this laughable establishment. These are all self-evident truths.”
“No. Not… not that.” The frustration gave you a spark of courage. You met his dial-eyed gaze. “Before. When I was alive. And now… it’s followed me here. It’s *in* me here.”
You fumbled for the concepts, the words that felt both too clinical and not precise enough. “They had a word for me. A box. It never… fit. It was like wearing shoes for the wrong feet. Everyone else seemed to walk just fine in theirs. They’d look at me, use that word, and it was like they were seeing someone else. A character I was forced to play.” Your voice grew tighter. “And I played it. Because what was the alternative? There wasn’t one. Not where I was. Not then.”
Alastor said nothing. He simply watched, his smile a carved monument.
“Then I died,” you continued, a hollow laugh escaping you. “Got here. And I thought… well, it’s Hell. All bets are off, right? The rules are gone. But the feeling… it wasn’t. It got *worse*. Because here, your form… it’s supposed to be *you*. Your sins, your soul, your… essence. So what does it mean that *this*,” you gestured vaguely at your own body, “still feels like a lie? What does it mean that the cage came with me?”
The static around him fluctuated, a low wave of distortion. You’d expected mockery. A cruel joke. A dismissal.
Instead, he was silent for a long, ponderous moment. Then, he unsteeped his fingers and gestured languidly to the sofa opposite him. “Sit.”
It wasn’t a request. You sat, perching on the edge, coiled tight.
“A… dissonance,” he said, the word crisp and clear. “Between the soul’s symphony and the body’s instrument. A most peculiar modern malaise. In my time, such discord was usually settled with a firm application of societal pressure and a generous helping of private misery. Much tidier.”
“Lucky you,” you muttered, unable to help yourself.
His grin widened a micron, showing more of his teeth. “Oh, indeed. But then, I never was one for internal conflict. I always knew precisely what I was: a man who enjoyed the broadcast, and later, a demon who enjoyed the scream.” He leaned back. “You, however, seem mired in the murk of metaphysics. You speak of cages and lies. You seek an ontological truth label. ‘What am I?’”
He made it sound so absurd. And in this setting, under his gaze, it was.
Your voice dropped to a whisper, the confession pulled from the deepest, most vulnerable part of you. “What am I, sir?”
The question hung in the air, vast and vulnerable. It seemed to suck the sound from the room, leaving only the faint, almost subliminal hum of his power. Alastor regarded you for a long, silent moment. The aggressive, crackling static softened to a gentle, background hum, like a radio tuned to a distant, peaceful station. He leaned back in his chair, his expression shifting from performative amusement to something contemplative, analytical.
“A fascinating and profoundly modern dilemma,” he mused, his voice losing its sharp broadcast edge, becoming more conversational, more… mentor-like. It was disorienting. “The tyranny of categories. The world of the living gave you one. A cage, but a familiar one. The key was in someone else’s hand, but you knew the dimensions of the bars. Then, the future—or the afterlife, or your own creeping self-awareness—gave you a different key. A key that seems, for the moment, to fit a lock you didn’t know you had. But the door is still part of the cage, you see? And that is terribly vexing.”
He tented his fingers again, peering at you over the apex. “You ask me what you are. A pointless question. You are yourself. A sinner. A soul. A *person.* A survivor. Broken. Whole. Damaged, yet determined. A fighter. A lover. These are facts, observable in your actions and your presence here. The labels ‘man’ or ‘woman,’ ‘this’ or ‘that’… they are social constructs, my dear—flimsy, temporary shelters mortals build to hide from the terrifying, glorious complexity of nature. Pathetic little boxes to make the census-taker’s job easier. In Hell,” he chuckled, a sound like rustling parchment, “such constructs are even more absurd. We are demons. Our forms are metaphors, punishments, aspirations. They are malleable. They shift with power, with desire, with rage. They are rarely binary. Look around!”
He unfolded a hand to gesture elegantly at the empty lobby. “Husk there—part man, part cat, all miserable cynicism. Niffty—a cyclone of activity in a tiny, cyclopic form. Angel Dust—well, his form is a statement and a lawsuit waiting to happen. And myself?” The static spiked briefly with pride. “I have chosen a form that evokes a specific era, a specific medium of terror. It is a *brand.* Not a birthright.”
He leaned forward slightly, the red light in his dial-eyes glinting. “The more pertinent question, the only question worth the breath to ask it, is: what do you *want* to be? Not what you are. What you *desire.* Desire is the currency of Hell. It is the engine of sin. It is, for better or worse, the closest thing we have to a true north.”
You stared at him. This wasn’t the advice you’d expected. It wasn’t warm, or gentle, or affirming in a way Charlie’s would have been—all rainbows and group hugs. It was cold, logical, and framed in the stark, selfish terms of damnation. And yet, it was the first thing that had ever made a sliver of sense.
“I… don’t know how to answer that,” you admitted.
“Of course you don’t!” he said, spreading his hands. The shadows in the room stretched and yawned, responding to his gesture. “You’ve spent a lifetime—and now an afterlife—listening to other people’s broadcasts. The static of their expectations, their definitions, their comfort. You need to find your own frequency. Tune out the noise.”
“How?” The word was a plea.
He shrugged, a sharp, elegant movement. “Experiment. This is Hell, not a finishing school. Your form is not stone. It is a manifestation of will, of soul-stuff. It is more fluid than you think. Do you feel a pull towards a different shape? A different presentation? A different *name*? Then try it on. Like one of Rosie’s hats in Cannibal Town! If it doesn’t suit you, discard it. No eternal harm done.”
“It’s not that simple,” you protested. “Everyone here sees me as… as what I look like now.”
“*Pah!*” A burst of static erupted from him. “Since when do you care what *anyone* here thinks? They are damned fools, every last one of them, clinging to their own pathetic narratives. The strong impose their reality upon the world. The weak suffer the reality imposed upon them.” His eyes narrowed. “Which are you?”
It was a challenge. A gauntlet thrown in the quiet lobby.
“I’m… scared,” you whispered, the truest confession of all.
For the first time, Alastor’s smile seemed to soften at the edges, not with warmth, but with a kind of intellectual recognition. “Now *that* is a sensible response. Fear is excellent fuel. It means the change matters. If it were easy, it would be trivial. This… confusion of yours. This dissonance. It is a source of power, if you choose to harness it. A unique fracture through which your true will can seep out. Most sinners are disappointingly one-note: angry, lustful, greedy. *Boring.* You have the potential for a more complex, interesting melody.”
He stood up abruptly, his shadow stretching to impossible lengths before snapping back to heel. He retrieved his microphone staff, the gentle hum returning to its more typical aggressive buzz. The moment of quasi-mentorship was closing.
“You came here seeking a definition. I refuse to give you one. Definitions are limits. And I *abhor* limits.” He began to walk away, towards the darkened hallway that led to his own radio tower, then paused, looking over his shoulder. “The hotel is full of well-meaning idiots who will offer you validation and group therapy. How dreary. I offer you a far greater gift: a challenge. Do not ask ‘what am I?’ Ask ‘what shall I become?’ And then, my dear… *broadcast it.*”
He vanished into the shadows, not with a pop, but with the fading signal of an old radio song, leaving you alone in the crimson-lit lobby.
The silence rushed back in, but it was different now. The gnawing, anxious static in your mind hadn’t vanished, but it had… changed frequency. It wasn’t just noise anymore. It was a signal, waiting to be shaped.
You looked down at your hands again. A sinner’s hands. But *your* hands. The cage he spoke of was still there, but he’d handed you not just a key, but a blueprint for a blowtorch. The terror remained, a cold knot in your stomach. But beneath it, for the first time since you could remember, there was a spark of something else. Not certainty. Not peace.
But possibility.
And in Hell, that was perhaps the most dangerous and precious thing of all.
You stood up from the sofa, feeling less like a phantom and more like a resident. The hotel slept on. But you were awake. You walked to the large window, looking out at the chaotic, terrible freedom of the Pentagram. Your reflection in the glass was vague, blurred by the neon signs outside.
*What shall I become?*
The question echoed, not with desperation, but with a nascent, terrifying will. You didn’t have an answer. Not yet.
But for the first time, you felt you had the right to ask it.